I think that FxCop, Reflector, CLRProfiler, and PIX – all of which I’ve previously discussed in some detail – are the most useful, bread-and-butter tools you’ll use in your XNA development. (In fact, all but perhaps PIX are useful regardless of whether you’re writing games or applications). There are of course many, many more tools, each with their uses, and I’d like to summarise some of them here. The sign of a good craftsman is using the right tool for the job, so I’d encourage you to explore all the different options available to you. Put bluntly, if you’re spending all your time performing repetitive tasks, or going through endless tweak-test-tweak-test cycles to try and hunt down problems in your code, you’re wasting your time. Your time may not be worth a lot to you, but mine is worth a lot to me, so I for one am always looking out for new tools and I think you should too.
Your primary development tool is Visual Studio itself (the Express version of which is available as a free download – possibly the most amazing free thing ever). I’m going to assume you already have it or you’d not be coding in XNA! However, I can guarantee that you are not using it to it’s full potential. I know I’m not. The reason I can make this guarantee is that the full potential of Visual Studio is huuuuuuuuuge. Almost every day, certainly every week, I discover new things it can do and think “that’s amazing!” Start by keeping up with the Visual Studio Tip of the Day, learn how to write macros, take some time to explore for yourself (especially consider keyboard shortcuts), and look out for plug-ins and extensions too. Project Line Counter is a personal favourite.
We’ve already looked at a couple of profiling tools but Perfmon (free with Windows) is the daddy of them all. As an example, hit Start then Run, and type “perfmon”. When the tool loads, select “Performance Monitor”, right-click on the counter list at the bottom and select “Add Counters…”. Select, say, the “.NET CLR Memory” category, then, for example, “% Time in GC”. Choose your game as the selected object and click “Add >>” then “OK”. Hey presto! A line displaying the exact processor cost you are paying for garbage collection will be added to the graph. There are hundreds of counters like this one, and much more that Perfmon can do.
I’m a bit loathe to mention this next one because, frankly, I hate it, but there are some bugs that can only be identified using WinDbg (or “windbag”, free with the Debugging Tools for Windows). Running out of memory and not sure why? Take a memory dump of your game, load sos.dll, call !DumpHeap -stat to see what’s live on the heap, call !DumpHeap -type <type> on the most memory-expensive type it lists to see all the items of that type, and call !GCRoot with the address of one of those objects to see exactly what is keeping it in memory and why. Sometimes there’s just no other way to work out what’s happening to your memory. WinDbg is an advanced tool and it’s an absolute swine to work with, but if the debugger in Visual Studio can’t solve your problem, WinDbg will.
I previously wrote about Reflector and described how it can reveal any assembly’s code to you. How does the code you write get translated from C# to the CLR and IL, and finally JIT-compiled into machine code? Well, I can’t help you with the JITter but IldAsm (free with Visual Studio) can provide a fascinating insight into the Intermediate Language stage of your code’s existence. Much in the same way that you don’t need to understand assembly language to write or use C++, but knowledge of assembly can help you fine-tune your C++ and fix the really tricky problems, knowledge of IL and an understanding of the translation process – while not essential – will make you a better C# programmer.
There’s a whole bunch of tools that are a bit more specialised or esoteric:
– Perforce is absolutely the best choice for source control. I can’t live without Perforce now, it’s as though it has become a part of me. It’s free for up to two users, though very expensive for larger teams than that (absolutely worth it if you’re a professional company, perhaps less so if you’re a group of hobbyists, in which case try Subversion).
– If you’re a pro developer and aren’t using continuous integration, you face months of torment in an endless death-march of crunch at the end of the project. Do yourself a favour and use CruiseControl .NET (free).
– Continuous integration becomes even more useful when a build is run against a set of unit tests, and in fact they’re useful for finding mistakes early which is good for anyone, pro or hobbyist alike. I’ve heard good things about NUnit (free)… do as I say, not as I do, and use it… not doing unit testing is my worst programming habit that one day I will get out of. Don’t fall into that trap.
– Perfmon can tell you when you’re slow on the CPU and CLRProfiler can tell you if it’s garbage at fault, but if not and you want to know which specific functions are slow (and you very often do!) NProf is the tool for you, and it’s free.
– Finally, I’ve not used it yet but RPM (Remote Performance Monitor for Xbox, free with XNA) looks to be pretty damn useful for working out why you’re running fine on PC but slow on 360.
The best thing about all of these tools? Like XNA itself, they’re all free. That’s the kind of money I’m OK with spending! It means you have no excuse for not becoming familiar with them and, hopefully, rather than staying up bleary-eyed until 5am trying to find the bug in your code, you can fire up the appropriate tool, find and fix the bug and be home in time to see your family and get a good night’s sleep. Everyone’s a winner!
There’s only one major category of tool I’m missing, and that’s a decent bug database. I’ve tried Bugzilla and OnTime, and at work we have to use Sunrise, and I hate all of them as well as some others. By far the best defect tracking system I used was Product Studio, when I was at Microsoft, but despite being brilliant it is only available with the Team System version of Visual Studio which is very expensive. If anyone can recommend a good, usable, simple bug database that is not web-based and has a good UI, please let me know.
In fact, undoubtedly many of you out there will have your own favourite tools. Why not share the love, leave a comment and let me and everyone else know which tools make your life easier?
“If the foreman knows and deploys his men well the finished work will be good.” – Miyamato Musashi